Join us for the 14th international MEX in London on 19th - 20th March 2014. 2 days where 100 creative thinkers learn, network and define the future of digital user experience.


Blyk to launch free MVNO supported by advertising

Much of the debate around mobile advertising has focused on a central question: what are users prepared to tolerate in return for less expensive or free services? Many research studies have tried to quantify that in one way or another. Harris Interactive, for instance, published a report stating 26 percent of US users would be willing to watch advertisements in return for free content on their mobile device, while 7 percent would accept text message advertising. RBC Capital Markets found that 58 percent of users considered mobile advertising a ‘nuisance which should be prohibited’ and 20 percent would accept advertising if it lowered the cost of their services.

As with so many metrics, you can interpret those however you wish. Some executives I’ve heard quoted will wax lyrical that 7 percent of a 200 million POP market like the US represents a huge opportunity, others will point to the same figures as an indication mobile advertising will ultimately flop because of consumer privacy concerns.

I’ve always felt these research studies are misleading because they are trying to answer the wrong question. Rather than resigning itself to the fact that mobile advertising will always be seen as a burden on the users, the industry should be looking at ways to enhance the advertising experience so that it is beneficial to the customer. I’ve summarised some of these ideas in my previous article entitled ‘Advertising – mission or exploration?‘ and there was further debate of the topic at the last MEX conference, which hosted a panel discussion under the same title.

It was refreshing to hear similar sentiments expressed by the management of Blyk, a new virtual network operator which is planning to launch a pan-European service offering free voice and text as part of an advertising-funded service. The venture, founded by former Nokia President Pekka Ala-Pietila and marketing veteran Antti Ohrling, will target the 16 to 24 age group with the promise of free calls and messages.

When I met with Ala-Pietila and Ohrling recently, they were keen to stress that they see the customer relationship as a ‘productive dialogue’ and that mobile advertising should be something the user values and wants to receive, rather than something which is tolerated only because it lowers costs. Blyk believes they can monetise the additional value this kind of relationship represents by selling it to enthusiastic advertisers.

The company are not yet discussing the exact details of the service, but according to Ala-Pietila they are investing a disproportionate amount of resources in the user experience as they prepare for a UK launch in the middle of next year. He believes they can create an entirely new ‘mobile media’ where users receive targeted advertisements in a way which is non-intrusive, valued and adapted to their particular usage habits. To achieve this, Blyk will collect a range of opt-in data when customers subscribe for the service and will also analyse usage patterns.

Marko Ahtisaari, head of brand and design for Blyk, expanded a little on this description, telling me that there would be no ‘bills’ as such, because almost all elements of the service will be offered free, and that the advertising will be delivered in a range of formats – from video to text to browsing – whichever is the most effective way of communicating. Indeed, it is Blyk’s objective to transcend these technological definitions and instead provide a service focused on results for the advertisers and a compelling experience for the customers.

Ohrling, whose currently serves as head of an international advertising agency, is well positioned to understand the opportunity from the media perspective. He sees agencies and brands already geared up to explore the possibilities of mobile, but frustrated by the lack of effective channels. Many of these companies missed the emergence of the internet as a medium and this has made them adopt pre-emptive strategies to ensure mobile does not also pass them by.

A January 2006 study by Vanson Bourne for Airwide Solutions, a messaging solutions provider, seems to confirm this. According to a survey of 50 major European brands, 87 percent were planning to conduct mobile marketing campaigns by 2008. 52 percent said they would be allocating between 5 and 25 percent of their total advertising budgets to mobile within 5 years. However, 55 percent were unsure about how to reach their audience through mobile, 58 percent did not know how to deploy an SMS campaign (with the figure rising to 61 percent for MMS).

One of Blyk’s major challenges will be engaging effectively with these advertisers and much of their work is in building the campaign management tools which will allow advertisers to track results and maintain a dialogue with customers. According to Ohrling, they will be unique in providing an integrated feedback mechanism for advertisements, allowing the clients to quickly gauge how well customers are responding to particular promotions.

This will not just be limited to major brands either. Ala-Pietila sees a role for Blyk in opening the mobile advertising channel to everyone from small local businesses to multi-nationals. He hopes Blyk will be able to work with all of these companies to help them create effective mobile advertising.

Blyk’s whole message is one of inclusion. The ‘free voice and SMS’ offer will no doubt be the focus of much attention because of the competitive connotations. However, Ala-Pietila insists the potential disruption Blyk causes will have a net ‘value creating’ effect for the mobile industry by bringing in a new source of revenue – advertising – without cannibalising overall ARPU. The founders argue that Blyk will actually help grow mobile wallet share among 16 to 24 year olds, traditionally quite a low ARPU group, because advertisers will be more capable of paying their bills than the invididuals themselves.

I recognise that Blyk is acting as an MVNO and will need to buy its minutes from an incumbent – and presumably will be charged for doing so in a way which maintains profitability for the operator – but I still think the reality will be an increase in price competition.

I will also be intrigued to see if Blyk can differentiate on anything other than price. It is not that this an ineffective way of building an MVNO – indeed, most successful MVNOs have been built around price competition – it is just that it is very difficult to be unique in this way. What happens when an incumbent network operator decides to start offering free, advertising-supported services to its much larger customer base? Blyk’s management was tight-lipped about future plans, but Ala-Pietila did tell me that they have some unique community capabilities which he believes will be very hard to replicate.

I can also imagine the disruptive potential of a service like this increasing substantially if it were linked with a wireless VoIP offering in the future. This would certainly give existing network operators something to think about at a time when so many in the industry seem to think value is slipping away from them – for more on this topic, see the debate on my recent article entitled ‘Why value is slipping away from the operators‘.

Blyk is still in the pre-launch stages and, given the attention their offering is likely to attract, they an unsurprisingly cautious about sharing the exact details of their plan. As such, I’m left with two main questions, which I also see as pertinent to the mobile advertising market in general:

- Do the economics work? Some quick ‘back of the envelope’ calculations reveal that an operator like Vodafone has a gross margin of about 41 percent, meaning that with an average monthly ARPU of GBP 21, it is costing them around GBP 12.40 to provide voice and text services to their customers. In my mind, that means Blyk will need to be generating at least GBP 10 – 15 in advertising revenue per customer per month to make a profit. I also wonder about the return on capital, as this will likely be an extremely marketing intensive undertaking, requiring significant investment during the initial stages of subscriber acquisition. The private investors and French VC Sofinnova who are backing Blyk will need deep pockets and patience.

- Does demand for ‘mobile advertising’ per-say really exist or will customers demand something more akin to search and discovery, i.e. mission completion tools? If this is the case, other players – such as Google and Yahoo – may have a more effective strategy in the mobile environment. Does Blyk’s decision to become an MVNO rather than just a mobile marketing provider confer any benefits if this scenario emerges?

Despite my uncertaintity over these questions, I have no doubt Blyk will cause a stir when it debuts. It is the free voice and texts which will capture the headlines, something which will no doubt be construed as the final push towards complete commoditisation of the mobile business. However, the long-term success of the venture will ultimately be determined by Blyk’s ability to understand customers, translate that understanding for advertisers and deliver an effective end-user experience which balances cost and usability. In this way, it will be judged on its ability to design a new value chain rather than how quickly it tears up the old.

9 comments - join the debate

  1. Yum Petkovic replied:

    Blyk’s approach is spot-on for the demographics they are targetting. This group had grown up around intense advertising on TV – anyone watching Cartoon Networks or Nickelodeon can testify to that! There will be some who would be adverse but most people, even seasoned individuals welcome a compelling experience, even in advertising. I think the most important aspect to Blyk’s mission is to deliver such experiences on a consistent basis in order to succeed. Like movies, good advertising turns messages into currency and generates stickiness. It becomes a repeat experience. That’s got to be good news for those involved. I would personally be looking forward to their launch to see if they can come up with the product that makes a difference.

    November 2nd, 2006 at 3:53 pm. Permalink.

  2. mac morrison replied:

    Indeed – hurrah for blyk, the target audience loves mobile, loves brands and loves advertising. It defines their outward self. But they don’t have the dosh (yet) to spend on the devices they desire. This brings the diamonds to claires accessories.

    November 2nd, 2006 at 4:31 pm. Permalink.

  3. Tech and Science News Updates! » Blog Archive » Another MVNO Takes Aim At The Free-Cell-Service-With-Ads Model replied:

    [...] e behind Blyk say they’ll send targeted ads to users, and they’ll be adds that offer value, rather than ones that are simply tolerated as a non-financial cost of service. They say t [...]

    November 2nd, 2006 at 5:50 pm. Permalink.

  4. Peter Cranstone replied:

    The critical element here is “relevancy”. The more relevant the ads the higher the value. The target demographic is probably spot on, what they need to be able to do to make it really valuable is pin-point the users actual location and deliver the ad based on location and his interests. Most phones come with GPS these days. It should be relatively easy to stream the actual GPS data directly to the advertising web server.

    Cheers,

    Peter

    November 2nd, 2006 at 7:02 pm. Permalink.

  5. Marek Pawlowski replied:

    Thanks for all your comments on this. Picking up on Peters point about relevancy, I’d agree this is an essential element. It is a complex thing for operators to understand, comprising everything from location to usage patterns to financial capabilities. Most operators have access to this information, I think the important difference with Blyk is it has been built from the ground up to take advantage of this asset – many existing network operators seem unable or willing to exploit the information in their legacy systems to deliver this kind of relevancy.

    November 3rd, 2006 at 10:28 am. Permalink.

  6. Scotty replied:

    Do you all remember Sugarmama from Virgin Mobile? It was all over the news this past summer… a revolutionary way for 15-25 year olds to pay for airtime.

    Then everything went silent. I guess it didn’t work. When a wireless company focused on youth can’t get an advertising model to work… i doubt a new startup can.

    November 7th, 2006 at 9:37 pm. Permalink.

  7. Bill Gates » The Super-Rich Get Richer: Forbes 400 All Billionaires (Washington Post) replied:

    [...] e behind Blyk say they’ll send targeted ads to users, and they’ll be adds that offer value, rather than ones that are simply tolerated as a non-financial cost of service. They say t [...]

    November 13th, 2006 at 8:03 pm. Permalink.

  8. Jon Mawby replied:

    Node have created a web based application on which GPS enabled devices fire media relevant to the location to create a unique, exciting and pertinent user experience.

    By combining this software with the user demographic there is vast potential for synchronising content and related advertising targeted at the user.

    The user will only be interested if the media is revelatory, interesting to them, and of high enough quality. With increasing wireless ubiquity the potential to continually update this information for the traveller or sports fan is hugley exciting.

    November 23rd, 2006 at 4:47 pm. Permalink.

  9. MEX - the strategy forum for mobile user experience - Can mobile advertising evolve beyond the mission?, pt. 2 replied:

    [...] r, has talked about the idea of making advertising a form of enertainment in itself. When we met with Blyk’s management in the pre-launch phase, they spoke of encouraging a new form of m [...]

    February 1st, 2007 at 11:26 am. Permalink.

Post a comment

Trackback URI


Spread the word


Subscribe

Read related articles

About the author
Marek Pawlowski Marek Pawlowski is the founder of MEX. Since 1995, he has focused the MEX business on helping digital industries to develop better, more profitable products through improved understanding of user behaviour with mobile devices and wireless networks. MEX is best known for its events, research and consulting, which balance commercial, technical and user insights to define the future of mobile user experience. Web http://www.pmn.co.uk/mex/ | Email mp@pmn.co.uk
Posted on
2 November 2006
Categories
Opinions, ideas and new thinking